Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge at San Diego Comic-Con

Image via Kevin Paul / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0). Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge at San Diego Comic-Con, July 2026.

Johnny Depp is back on the big screen, and nobody can agree on whether it works. His new film Ebenezer is out today in cinemas, and the critics are split almost exactly down the middle.

The film is a dark, gothic take on Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol. Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge, the miser who gets one last chance at redemption when the spirits of Christmas Past, Present and Future pay him a visit. It is his first major studio lead in about eight years, and Hollywood is watching the box office closely to see if he can still open a film.

Critics split right down the middle

The first reviews landed on Thursday, and the numbers tell the story. Ebenezer debuted on Rotten Tomatoes at around 50 percent. At one count, 35 reviews were fresh and 34 were rotten. That is about as close to a perfect split as a big release gets. On Metacritic, the film sits at 47 out of 100.

The split runs through the reviews themselves. The Guardian says Depp is "rather good" as Scrooge. The Hollywood Reporter says his charisma and star power come through in the end. MovieWeb gave the film four out of five and called it Depp's best showcase in years. The Daily Telegraph gave it four stars too.

But the other half of the critics see the same performance and reach the opposite verdict. The Boston Globe called Depp "easily the worst Scrooge I've ever seen" and gave the film one star out of four. IndieWire's David Ehrlich gave it a C+ and blamed the casting. Consequence gave it a D+. The Independent gave it two stars out of five.

So the film's fate will be decided at the box office, not by the critics. And the early signs say audiences may be kinder than reviewers. Test audiences scored the film 80 out of 100, according to Puck, and Depp himself scored 86, well above the 67 a lead actor usually gets. Early audience ratings put it at 90 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, with four stars on PostTrak.

The box office test

Ebenezer took $1.5 million from Thursday preview screenings, according to Variety. That lands right where the trackers expected it to. Heading into the weekend, the film is projected to open at $20 million to $23 million in North America, with a similar amount expected from 63 overseas markets. Boxoffice Pro puts it at No. 1 for the weekend, with a $20 million to $25 million range, across more than 3,500 theatres.

If it lands there, it will be Depp's first No. 1 opening since Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald in 2018. It would also be a win on the film's own terms. Paramount made it for a reported $38 million, which is low by the standards of Depp's old studio vehicles. Depp took a reported $5 million salary, a fraction of his peak-era pay, tied to performance bonuses. Marketing cost around $50 million, more than the film itself, because Paramount bet on making sure everyone knew the film and its star existed.

The stakes go beyond one Christmas film. Depp has not headlined a major Hollywood studio release since before his 2022 defamation trial, and studios stepped back from him in the years before that. Paramount has backed this one hard, from showing footage at CinemaCon in April to Depp turning up at Comic-Con in full Scrooge costume, shouting "humbug" at passers-by. The trailer sells it as the return of the "master of misfits", with Depp telling the camera directly: "It's good to be back."

Even the release date is part of the pitch. A dark, ghostly Christmas Carol landing on Friday the 13th is exactly the kind of timing a studio hopes will turn a film into an event. The long holiday season ahead gives it room to keep earning through Christmas if audiences take to it.

EbenezerDetails
Out todayFriday 13 November 2026, in US and UK cinemas
Runtime116 minutes (1 hour 56 minutes)
RatingPG-13
DirectorTi West (X, Pearl, MaXXXine)
WriterNathaniel Halpern
StudioParamount Pictures
BudgetReported $38 million

Who plays who

Depp is Scrooge, aged up under prosthetics, with Ian McKellen as his old business partner Jacob Marley. Andrea Riseborough plays the Ghost of Christmas Past, Tramell Tillman plays the Ghost of Christmas Present, and Rupert Grint plays Bob Cratchit. Sam Claflin is Scrooge's nephew Fred, and Daisy Ridley plays Fred's wife Clara.

CharacterActor
Ebenezer ScroogeJohnny Depp
Jacob MarleyIan McKellen
Ghost of Christmas PastAndrea Riseborough
Ghost of Christmas PresentTramell Tillman
Bob CratchitRupert Grint
FredSam Claflin
ClaraDaisy Ridley

What the reviews say

OutletVerdict
Rotten TomatoesAround 50% (35 fresh, 34 rotten at one count)
Metacritic47 out of 100
MovieWeb4 out of 5 — Depp's best showcase in years
The Daily Telegraph4 out of 5
The Guardian3 out of 5 — Depp is "rather good"
The Hollywood ReporterPositive — his charisma comes through
IndieWireC+ — blames the casting
The Boston Globe1 out of 4 — "worst Scrooge I've ever seen"
ConsequenceD+
The Independent2 out of 5
Test audiences (Puck)80 out of 100; Depp scored 86
Early audience score90% on Rotten Tomatoes, 4 stars on PostTrak

The weekend ahead

Ebenezer does not have the weekend to itself. How to Rob a Bank, David Leitch's heist film with Nicholas Hoult and Pete Davidson, opened in cinemas on the same day, while Heartland arrived on Netflix and 12 12 12 landed on Apple TV. But the forecasters still see Depp's Scrooge as the frontrunner for the top spot. The weekend estimates will give the first real answer to the question the whole campaign has been asking: can Johnny Depp still open a film?

A No. 1 finish in the low $20 millions, with holiday legs through December, would show he can. A soft opening would leave the film remembered mainly as a curiosity: a dark, Friday-the-13th Christmas Carol that split the critics down the middle and could not settle the argument over its star. Either way, nobody is indifferent to Johnny Depp playing Scrooge. For a film opening today, that may be the most valuable thing of all.

Read More: How to Rob a Bank Out Today: Nicholas Hoult and Pete Davidson's Heist Film, Cast and Reviews

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post